10 Best Practices for Nonprofit Board Success

Nonprofit Board meeting

Nonprofit organizations play a vital role in addressing societal challenges and fostering positive change. At the heart of these organizations lies your board of directors, a group of dedicated individuals who guide the mission and vision of your organization. Effective nonprofit board development is essential for ensuring your organization not only survives but thrives in your pursuit of meaningful impact. 

The Importance of Strong Nonprofit Boards  

Nonprofit boards serve as the backbone of an organization, offering strategic guidance, oversight, and leadership. A well-rounded board brings diverse skills, experiences, and perspectives to the table, enriching decision-making processes. Board members often lend their expertise in areas such as finance, law, marketing, and community engagement, contributing to a comprehensive and multifaceted approach to organizational management. 

Building a robust board is not just about assembling individuals. Here are some essential practices every nonprofit needs to impact board success.   

  1. Clear Vision and Mission Alignment: Prospective and current board members should share a deep connection with your nonprofit's mission and vision. When the passion for the cause aligns with their individual values, board members are more likely to be committed and engaged in driving your organization's goals. 

  2. Diversity and Inclusion: A diverse board reflects the communities your nonprofit serves and enhances the quality of decision-making. Inclusive boards with members from various backgrounds bring a range of viewpoints, fostering innovation and a deeper understanding of your organization's impact.  Provide support to new board members from underrepresented groups to help them acclimate to the board and feel included.  This could include assigning a mentor, providing training, or connecting them with other members who have similar backgrounds or experiences.  Encourage open communication and create opportunities for all board members to share their ideas and opinions in a safe space.  

  3. Effective Governance Structure: Nonprofit boards should establish a governance structure that defines roles, responsibilities, and decision-making processes. This structure clarifies the hierarchy, facilitates communication, and prevents conflicts.  

  4. Skills Assessment: Identifying the skills and expertise needed on the board is crucial. Conducting a skills assessment can help pinpoint gaps and inform recruitment efforts. Whether it's legal knowledge, fundraising prowess, or technology acumen, each skill set contributes to a well-rounded board. There are countless great (and free!) templates online to help you create your assessment tool.   

  5. Recruitment Strategies: Engage in deliberate recruitment efforts to attract potential board members. Leverage personal networks, professional associations, and community organizations to identify individuals who align with the organization's mission and possess the required skills. 

  6. Orientation and Training: Once selected, new board members should receive a comprehensive orientation to understand their roles, responsibilities, and the organization's operations. Providing ongoing training ensures board members remain informed about industry trends, governance best practices, and the nonprofit's evolving needs.  Ensure that all board members know that they have equal opportunities to participate in meetings and decision-making processes. 

  7. Commitment and Accountability: Board members must commit to attending meetings regularly and actively participating in discussions. Clear expectations regarding attendance, preparation, and engagement should be set to maintain a high level of accountability.  Regularly assess board member engagement and satisfaction to ensure that all members feel valued, included, and supported.    

  8. Strategic Planning: Boards play a crucial role in setting the nonprofit's strategic direction. Collaboratively developing a strategic plan ensures that all board members are aligned with the organization's long-term goals and objectives. 

  9. Evaluation and Feedback: Regular board evaluations allow for self-assessment and identify areas for improvement. This process fosters open dialogue and creates a culture of continuous growth and enhancement. 

  10. Succession Planning: Anticipating the departure of board members is essential. A well-executed succession plan ensures a seamless transition and prevents disruptions in governance and leadership.  Take time to recognize and express appreciation for board members as their terms conclude or they depart on good terms not as just a gesture of gratitude but also a testament to the value they've added and the meaningful contributions they've made to your organization's mission and success. 

Nonprofit board development is crucial, serving as the foundation of organizational efficacy and impact. By nurturing a diverse, engaged, and skilled board, you can navigate challenges, seize opportunities, and fulfill your mission with unwavering dedication. Through ongoing cultivation, inclusivity, and a collaborative culture, you can drive sustainable growth and maximize your positive influence on communities and those you serve and impact.  Investing in board development isn't just strategic; it's a commitment to unlocking the full potential of your nonprofit in creating lasting change and a brighter future. 


A fundraising consultant at M. Gale, Christina Moore-Salinas, CFRE, enjoys sharing a common goal with clients. “It’s inspiring to see the dedication and passion that nonprofit teams have for their cause. To be a part of that effort is truly fulfilling. I enjoy getting to know an organization’s mission and values and see firsthand the impact they have on the community.”

Outside of work, Christina is passionate about all things theater – ballet, opera, symphony, concerts, and musicals! Ask her about which Broadway performance she’s seen 42 times.

Previous
Previous

As I See It: A Conversation 15 Years in the Making With Missy Gale

Next
Next

As I See It: Treat Annual Donors Like the Loyal Friends They Are